When I posted Wet 'n' Wild Los Feliz Navidad a while back, more than a few folks said that it might be a dupe for OPI Alcatraz Rocks. I realized that I had it in my untrieds...so I decided to break it out and compare the two!
Los Feliz Navidad is an indigo texture with a mix of small and large glitters. It is opaque in two coats and heavily textured.
Alcatraz Rocks is a more violet shade, with a less diverse collection of glitters. The texture is a bit smoother as well.
In the bottle, they are very different. The WnW has a brighter look to it, and is much more reflective. The OPI is a darker, moodier feeling, with all the sparkle and shift subdued by the deep base.
On the nail, they are totally different. I was not expecting them to be this different.
|index and middle: Alcatraz Rocks
ring and pinky: Los Feliz Navidad
They look the most similar in the macro pictures. You can see that they have a similar shift to them, even though the colors are different. It is almost like the WnW is a faded version of the OPI
The tl;dr is that these are half-sisters, at best. Definitely not dupes. But if you are pressed for cash, then I would recommend the Wet 'n' Wild. It is less than three bucks (without coupons) and it does the job well enough.
I guess for a texture...they are both ok. I guess.